Wednesday, November 18, 2026

THE COURSE OF THE HEART, by M. John Harrison, 1992

Cover by Dave McKean. Click for a better jpeg.

Writers cut their own pathways, and we, as readers, must accept their choices, even if we find ourselves unable to follow. For two decades, I followed M. John Harrison's work, studied it, and learned as much as I could from it.

His books and stories from the 1970s combined science fiction imagery with personal touches of observation and feeling; they were built on landscapes that Harrison knew, and this brought physical details and images that made his work live.

From THE MACHINE IN SHAFT TEN, 1975. London Melancholy. Click for a better jpeg.

In the 1980s, he tossed aside typical science fiction concepts and replaced them with personal experience, with a deeper concern for human frailties and frustrations, all of this rooted, as always, in the landscapes that he knew and loved.

From THE ICE MONKEY, 1983. The New Rays. Click for a better jpeg.

This period of his work spoke to me with a new vividness and emotional resonance; I considered THE ICE MONKEY, from 1983, his best collection, and THE COURSE OF THE HEART, from 1992, his best novel.

After this, in the period that began with TRAVEL ARRANGEMENTS, from 2000, and with LIGHT, from 2002, Harrison lost me. LIGHT was a return to science fiction, and in leaving Earth behind, Harrison also ditched the qualities of personal experience and close observation that had made his work vivid. His prose became less concerned with sensory detail, more abstract, more dry and clinical in its moods. He was off on a new pathway, but not a path I could follow.

I was reminded of this change when I tried to read his latest novel, THE END OF EVERYTHING, a book that defeated me within a few dozen pages. I found the writing even more detached from human feeling, from sensory detail, from personal observation, even more dry and abstract. In what I had read of the book before I quit, I found none of the qualities that had made his earlier stories matter to me, that had so impressed me in THE COURSE OF THE HEART.

That book was an expansion of "The Great God Pan," from 1988, a story that alludes in its title to Arthur Machen, and an excellent horror tale on its own terms. In adding to its material, Harrison shifted the mood away from horror into a fantasy based on down-to-Earth characters closely observed and keenly felt. All of the virtues of his 1980s work are here, along with a depth of compassion, an economy of means, that go beyond even his excellent earlier stories.

Settings are painted with clear, brief strokes:

The house, like many in the Pennines, had been built right into the side of the valley. A near-vertical bank of earth, cut to accommodate it, was held back by a dry-stone revetment twenty or thirty feet high, black with damp even in the middle of July, dusted with lichen and tufted with ferns like a cliff. Throughout the winter months, water streamed down the revetment day after day and, collecting in a stone trough underneath, made a sound like a tap left running in the night. Along the back of the house ran a passage hardly two feet wide, full of broken roof slates and other rubbish.

---

By now it was dark outside, but the younger cat was still staring out into the greyish, sleety well of the garden, beyond which you could just make out -- as a swelling line of shadow with low clouds racing over it -- the edge of the moor. Pam kept asking the cat what it could see. 'Nothing but old crimes out there,' she told it. 'Children buried all over the moor.'

People, too, come to life:

'As children none of the women in that family would ever go to sleep,' he had once written to me.

'You see them in photographs at three years old, almost blind with tiredness, puffy-eyed, heavy-lidded as vamps from a silent film, white, thin, with expressions as old and vulnerable as baby mice. They won’t let go. They won’t give in. In later life, rather than sleep, they smoke another cigarette, make another cup of instant coffee, read another page of LOST HORIZON.'

---

'The first time I had a fit,' she said, 'I kept it from my mother because I saw a vision with it. I was only a child, really. The vision was very clear: a seashore, steep and with no sand, and men and women lying on some rocks in the sunshine like lizards, staring quite blankly at the spray as it exploded up in front of them; huge waves that might have been on a cinema screen for all the notice they took of them.'

She narrowed her eyes, puzzled.

'You wondered why they had so little common sense.'

She tried to push the cat off her bed, but it only bent its body in a rubbery way and avoided her hand. She yawned suddenly.

'At the same time,' she went on, after a pause, 'I could see that some spiders had made their webs between the rocks, just a foot or two above the tideline.' Though they trembled and were sometimes filled with spray like dewdrops so that they glittered in the sun, the webs remained unbroken. She couldn't describe, she said, the sense of frailty and anxiety with which this filled her. 'So close to all that violence. You wondered why they had so little common sense,' she repeated. 'The last thing I heard was someone warning me, "On your own you really can hear voices in the tide --"'

---

"As the train crawled the last mile into London, I had seen three sheets of newspaper fluttering round the upper floors of an office block like butterflies courting a flower. The Pleroma demands of us a passion for the world which, however distortedly, reflects it. I still remember the intelligent eagerness of the negro's smile -- how he always had to talk about the world -- the way his sharp-edged elegant cheekbones seemed, like tribal scars or a silk suit, to be more designed than organic."

This Pleroma, the spiritual realm described by the Gnostics, becomes the fascination of three Cambridge students who are led by an unreliable occultist, Yaxley, into a dangerous ritual:

'Nobody tricked them, or tried to pretend it would be easy. If you get anything out of an experiment like that, it's by keeping your head and taking your chance. If you try to move cautiously, you may never be allowed to move at all.'

He looked thoughtful.

'I've seen what happens to people who lose their nerve.'

'I'm sure,' I said.

'They were hardly recognisable, some of them.'

I put the teacup down.

'I don't want to know,' I said.

'I bet you don't.'

He smiled to himself.

'Oh, they were still alive,' he said softly, 'if that's what you're worried about.'

This occult experiment took place twenty years before the book begins. The rest of the novel shows the ripples and echoes of that impact, the distortions and revelations that it leaves behind.

'You're all right,' I told Pam, who was staring, puzzled, into the gathering dark, her head on one side and the tea towel held up to her mouth as if she thought she was going to be sick.

'It knows who we are,' she whispered. 'Despite the precautions, it always remembers us.'

Haunted and wounded by their experience, the characters do their best to lead normal human lives, but wherever they go, whatever they do, the Pleroma follows. Yet this haunting is not merely a series of threats and intrusions; it also provides revelations and everyday insights.

'Look, Lucas: the world's ours. We make it, minute to minute. Pam would never admit that. It frightened her to have responsibility for her own needs. She wanted the universe personalised. A father who would look out for her. Happy accidents. Gifts. Things that came demonstrably from outside, so she felt special. That's the biggest lie of all.'

As the characters age, the novel shows how they cope and adapt to their new circumstances, how they deal with outbursts of nightmare and equally shocking moments of beauty.

Harrison wrote THE COURSE OF THE HEART during what was, for him, a period of skepticism about genre limitations, and a search for methods of writing that would allow him to apply his own experience and sensibility to fiction. He was also concerned with the longing for transcendence, even if only through imagination and fantasy. The result is a book unafraid to confront the real world, unafraid to show, with candour and compassion, the frailty and endurance of everyday lives within a context of impossible events.

I find THE COURSE OF THE HEART excellent both as fantasy and as a novel: emotionally compelling, aesthetically thrilling, honest, and in the end, moving.

Tuesday, November 3, 2026

The Blood On Satan's Claw

Click for a better jpeg.

THE BLOOD ON SATAN'S CLAW (aka SATAN'S SKIN), 1971. Written by Robert Wynne-Simmons and Piers Haggard. Directed by Piers Haggard.

After several viewings, the film continues to disappoint me, but at the same time, it offers details I respect.

I can praise the simple but effectively eerie score by Marc Wilkinson. I admire the cinematography of Dick Bush, who relies on windows and fireplaces to provide chiaroscuro lighting, and who enhances the beauty of several strikingly attractive women. The film's direction offers good moments of stage blocking and action, especially in one shot where an empty forest is revealed to be full of people. The film brims with a stark, late autumn atmosphere, and it opens with a promisingly spooky sequence in which a farmer in a plowed field uncovers a monstrous face.

Where the film falls apart is in the script. It relies on the characters to act according to the needs of the plot, which often makes their actions hard to fathom.

For example: The visiting fiancee of an upper-class young man is forced by his disapproving uncle, the Judge, to spend the night away from the rest of his family in their creepy attic. Suddenly, she begins to scream. So great is her fear that she lashes out at the woman who comes to rescue her.

What does the Judge do? Does he try to understand what has terrified this woman? No, he slams the attic door and leaves her trapped inside.

"Nail the door shut!" he says. "She's fit only for Bedlam. I'll have two men take her away in the morning."

The judge had already been established as a cold-hearted man who disdains the "simple" country folk around him, but this goes beyond characterization into narrative convenience. The plot requires that the Judge lock up the girl, and so he does.

Later on, the woman's fiance, mourning her forced absence, goes up to the attic and is attacked by a clawed and hairy paw that reaches out from under the floorboards. He fights it off, and blocks it under the floor with a heavy chest. Then he gets the hell out of that creepy attic, right?

No! He lies down beside the chest and goes to sleep as if nothing had happened.

When characters ignore their own logic to follow the illogic of a badly-developed plot, it can lead to unmotivated shifts in character consistency.

Another example. These are not direct quotations; the sarcasm is mine.

DOCTOR: I suspect witchcraft.

JUDGE: Witchcraft is dead, and discredited.

DOCTOR: But I have a book, here, all about witchcraft. Look at this crude woodcut. Doesn't it resemble the fiend that neither of us actually saw? The fiend that you mocked as mere animal remains, and a waste of your time?

JUDGE: Might I request the loan of this book? It might merit further study.

How convenient for the plot!

Then the cold-hearted Judge goes away for half the film. Why? Business elsewhere: hardly a strong motivation. At the end of the film, he returns to become the conquering hero, because the script needed someone to do it. He also returns as an expert in fighting witchcraft, because the script needed him to be one.

Plausible reasons for character change? Not in this film.

Beyond its need for the characters to act unrealistically to suit the plot, the great limitation of the film is that it becomes episodic and arbitrary. Characters arrive and depart; major characters fade into the background and give way to new major characters never properly introduced; important events take place (or so we are told) off-camera. The film is like a crowded party in which faces loom at you and then retreat before you can grasp who they are. This makes THE BLOOD ON SATAN'S CLAW seem like a multi-episode TV serial that had been chopped-up and awkwardly condensed into 90 minutes.

And so the film goes on, looking good, sounding good, with unmotivated actions by the inconsistent characters, until the finale, in which evil is vanquished with disappointing ease. The end, fade to black, drive carefully on your way home.

This is a film hard to recommend, yet at the same time, a film hard to ignore. What it does well, it does very well; what it does badly is a damned shame.

Sunday, November 1, 2026

Horror Fiction, Horror Films: No Maps, No Borders? Or Aesthetic Fundamentalism?

Aesthetic fundamentalism: the idea that certain forms of writing or filmmaking must be restricted to a limited range of elements and methods.

This becomes odd when applied to any field unlimited by tradition, any field that can absorb variations and hybrids without end, while remaining characteristically itself. For example, horror.

Horror is not a genre, limited by expectations or styles, but a mood, an emotional or intellectual response that can be prompted by any number of ideas and approaches. This refusal to be limited means that readers and viewers of horror can form their own aesthetic preferences.

An aesthetic preference is harmless, even useful, as long as we recognize that it reveals more about ourselves, about our own wants and needs, than it does about the field as a whole. For my part, I find more of what I love about horror in the writings of Thomas de Quincey or Walter de la Mare, in Elizabeth Bowen or William Sansom, than I have ever found in Lovecraft. I find more uncanny atmosphere in a non-horror book like L. P. Hartley's THE GO-BETWEEN, than in anything I've read or tried to read by Stephen King; more dread and strangeness in the films of Bergman, Tarkovsky, and Lynch, than in films from Roger Corman or Hammer. Yet I recognize that for many people, King and Lovecraft, Hammer and Corman are what horror means. Their preferences, and mine, are neither wrong nor right, but merely personal and subjective.

Yet I still meet opposition to this idea that aesthetic assessments are subjective -- inevitably subjective, given the size of the field, the sheer number of books and films available over the decades and centuries, the wide range of plots and images, tones evoked and methods applied; no single aesthetic preference could cover so much varied material.

I find this opposition all the more baffling because, for me, a great attraction of horror is the lack of maps, the open borders, the endless possibilities for personal expression and personal satisfaction. Its freedom from genre expectations gives horror the advantage of surprise; it can be found in the least expected places, as in the stories of Isaac Babel or John Cheever, as in a down-to-Earth, slice-of-life book like Sarah Orne Jewett's THE COUNTRY OF THE POINTED FIRS. As a reader, as a watcher of movies, I take pleasure in being caught off guard, in finding the unexpected in the most unlikely stories and films.

Others disagree. They seem to want the expected, the usual. I have heard some people argue that for many readers and viewers, horror is comfortable, familiar, reassuring in its repeated elements and methods, but I find this hard to believe, if only because horror, by the extremity of its emotional impact, seems more likely to shock and unsettle than to comfort. Yet the repetitions, the rituals of Dracula and Cthulhu, Freddy Krueger and Jason, have always been more popular than LES YEUX SANS VISAGE, PERSONA, SECONDS, or FAIL SAFE. There would seem to be a pattern, here, of preferences in horror, of old things desired, of novelties avoided.

In the end, patterns count for less than personal tastes. Horror provides a field wide enough for everyone. Whether we choose to explore its length, or to sit quietly in one place, or to build fortresses and borders within this infinite realm, we choose for purposes that suit our own needs. The field itself goes on and on.

Tuesday, October 27, 2026

Great Director, Lousy Script: John Carpenter and "Cigarette Burns"

Click for a better jpeg, if not for a better film.

Twenty years ago, when I watched John Carpenter's "Cigarette Burns," I found it a disappointing mess. Having watched it again, I feel that I was generous in my assessment. I blame the script by Drew McWeeny and Scott Swan, but I also blame Carpenter, who is too good a director not to have noticed how the script falls apart.

Yet even a failed story can offer something to think about, or in this case, writing mistakes to avoid.

1) Seven minutes into the film, the protagonist is given a clear view of something uncanny, of something perhaps even supernatural. His response? Nothing. He sees it, and walks away.

Under the circumstances, most people would ask, "What are you showing me? What the hell is THIS?" Smart people would run away, and want nothing more to do with it. Yet the blank protagonist seems untouched by this encounter, perhaps because the plot requires that he remain untouched.

This puts the emphasis backwards. In a good film like Jacques Tourneur's NIGHT OF THE DEMON, the protagonist, a skeptic, encounters hints of the supernatural, but as a rational man, he refuses to accept them as anything more than tricks of stage magic and psychology. Only as the plot develops does he begin to recognize the danger he faces. That the film shows the viewers, right from the start, that this is indeed a tale of the supernatural, does nothing to undermine the protagonist's movement from skepticism to alert awareness. In contrast, the protagonist of "Cigarette Burns," warned with immediate, direct evidence of something terribly wrong, seems like a fool.

2) When a story builds up the idea that something horrible is out there, waiting to be revealed, the pay-off should justify the build-up. For example, in THE SHOUT (hardly a favourite of mine), the Shout is presented as a terrible magical weapon, and when it finally comes into use, the film succeeds (for me, at least) in making its impact appropriately disturbing. That moment hit me, just as the moment when Mrs. Bates is finally revealed hit me, just as the "kennel" moment in John Carpenter's THE THING hit me.

In contrast, when shots of the legendary horror film at the centre of "Cigarette Burns" are finally revealed, they offer nothing that has not been shown in the story before this; they offer no sense of anything unusual or shocking. Indeed, they offer standard images that you could find in any horror film, so what was the point of that build-up?

No, "Cigarette Burns" is a mistake. I respect John Carpenter, I love many of his films, but this one serves only to warn the rest of us of what not to do.

M. R. James, "Casting The Runes," and NIGHT OF THE DEMON

Click for a better jpeg.

In 1977, I considered "Casting The Runes" one of the lesser stories by M. R. James. In 2025, I can see how wrong I was.

It brings to life two Jamesian principles:

1) If you can get away with silence, then say nothing.

"It is not necessary to tell in further detail the steps by which Henry Harrington and Dunning were brought together."

---

"After a judicious interval, Harrington repeated to Dunning something of what he had heard his brother say in his sleep: but it was not long before Dunning stopped him."

2) If the story forces you to spell out the details, then do it rapidly and clearly.

"The stories kept on becoming a little more terrifying each time, and the children were mesmerised into complete silence. At last he produced a series which represented a little boy passing through his own park -- Lufford, I mean -- in the evening. Every child in the room could recognize the place from the pictures. And this poor boy was followed, and at last pursued and overtaken, and either torn in pieces or somehow made away with, by a horrible hopping creature in white, which you saw first dodging about among the trees, and gradually it appeared more and more plainly. Mr Farrer said it gave him one of the worst nightmares he ever remembered, and what it must have meant to the children doesn't bear thinking of."

---

"He put his hand into the well-known nook under the pillow: only, it did not get so far. What he touched was, according to his account, a mouth, with teeth, and with hair about it, and, he declares, not the mouth of a human being."

---

"'Ad he got a dog with him, or what? Funny thing: I could 'a' swore 'e wasn’t alone.'"

The results are lean and propulsive. The story stalks in, punches you in the face, then glides off into the dusk.

NIGHT OF THE DEMON, the 1957 film adaptation by Jacques Tourneur, transforms many set-pieces from the story into sequences equally powerful, and adds a few of its own (the children's party, the Hobart farm, the final confrontation at the train-yard). It also replaces one of the story's protagonists, Henry Harrington, with Peggy Cummins, very much to my pleasure.

The film also reveals its demon right from the start. Even though Tourneur had objected to this, I call it a strength: it shows the audience, right away, that the film's protagonist will be in serious trouble, that he is walking into a trap of his own disbelief.

This opposition between belief and disbelief, between superstition and science, was not a component of the short story. In the film it becomes a central conflict, but a conflict with nuance:

In "Casting the Runes", Karswell's intended victim is an expert on alchemical history, who rejects Karswell's scholarship as "perfectly hopeless". In NIGHT OF THE DEMON, psychologist John Holden is an American delegate to a conference on parapsychology, devoted, in part, to investigating and debunking the Karswell devil-cult. Primary investigator Harrington had died mysteriously; his niece, Joanna Harrington, believes that Karswell's magic is responsible. Karswell openly curses Holden, predicts his death right to the hour, and tells him that his mind will crack from sheer terror. Holden, rationalist and complete skeptic, calls it a bunch of nonsense... until he realizes that Karswell's game is a true manifestation of black magic.

Yet even though NIGHT OF THE DEMON revels in the supernatural power of Karswell, it ends with John Holden beating the curse by remaining a scientist. Harrington had died in panic, but Holden, calmly analytical, wins. (Joanna, too, stays calm and observant despite her belief in the supernatural: "John, he's terrified of you... He's lying... I saw it with my own eyes."). Even in the face of a clearly supernatural threat, the heroes keep their heads, and this makes all the difference in the fight against Karswell.

Much has been said about Karswell and the performance of Niall McGinnis. A vague, barely glimpsed presence in "Runes" -- stout, secretive and surly -- he becomes an arrogantly real person in NIGHT OF THE DEMON. This is one of the film's many triumphs, and I agree that Karswell steals the show.

Other thiefs are the cinematography of Ted Scaife, the low-ceilinged, shadowy set designs of Ken Adam (I love that Hobart farm!), and especially the music of Clifton Parker, in one of my favourite horror scores.

Another striking aspect of the film (also present in the short story) is that, for all its talk of devils and demons, there is no mention of churches or angels. Not even Indian scientist Kumar, a firm believer in devils, has anything to say about gods or divine mercy. At no point is there any suggestion that prayer or sanctuary will keep Holden from his fate; his only hope lies in cleverness and rationality, in beating evil at its own game. I admire this approach: with no belief in gods or in the supernatural, I can still play along happily with a film that respects my intelligence even as it conjures up a world of relentless, black magic monsters. In this, and more, NIGHT OF THE DEMON is a great respecter of its audience.