Wednesday, November 18, 2026

THE COURSE OF THE HEART, by M. John Harrison, 1992

Cover by Dave McKean. Click for a better jpeg.

Writers cut their own pathways, and we, as readers, must accept their choices, even if we find ourselves unable to follow. For two decades, I followed M. John Harrison's work, studied it, and learned as much as I could from it.

His books and stories from the 1970s combined science fiction imagery with personal touches of observation and feeling; they were built on landscapes that Harrison knew, and this brought physical details and images that made his work live.

From THE MACHINE IN SHAFT TEN, 1975. London Melancholy. Click for a better jpeg.

In the 1980s, he tossed aside typical science fiction concepts and replaced them with personal experience, with a deeper concern for human frailties and frustrations, all of this rooted, as always, in the landscapes that he knew and loved.

From THE ICE MONKEY, 1983. The New Rays. Click for a better jpeg.

This period of his work spoke to me with a new vividness and emotional resonance; I considered THE ICE MONKEY, from 1983, his best collection, and THE COURSE OF THE HEART, from 1992, his best novel.

After this, in the period that began with TRAVEL ARRANGEMENTS, from 2000, and with LIGHT, from 2002, Harrison lost me. LIGHT was a return to science fiction, and in leaving Earth behind, Harrison also ditched the qualities of personal experience and close observation that had made his work vivid. His prose became less concerned with sensory detail, more abstract, more dry and clinical in its moods. He was off on a new pathway, but not a path I could follow.

I was reminded of this change when I tried to read his latest novel, THE END OF EVERYTHING, a book that defeated me within a few dozen pages. I found the writing even more detached from human feeling, from sensory detail, from personal observation, even more dry and abstract. In what I had read of the book before I quit, I found none of the qualities that had made his earlier stories matter to me, that had so impressed me in THE COURSE OF THE HEART.

That book was an expansion of "The Great God Pan," from 1988, a story that alludes in its title to Arthur Machen, and an excellent horror tale on its own terms. In adding to its material, Harrison shifted the mood away from horror into a fantasy based on down-to-Earth characters closely observed and keenly felt. All of the virtues of his 1980s work are here, along with a depth of compassion, an economy of means, that go beyond even his excellent earlier stories.

Settings are painted with clear, brief strokes:

The house, like many in the Pennines, had been built right into the side of the valley. A near-vertical bank of earth, cut to accommodate it, was held back by a dry-stone revetment twenty or thirty feet high, black with damp even in the middle of July, dusted with lichen and tufted with ferns like a cliff. Throughout the winter months, water streamed down the revetment day after day and, collecting in a stone trough underneath, made a sound like a tap left running in the night. Along the back of the house ran a passage hardly two feet wide, full of broken roof slates and other rubbish.

---

By now it was dark outside, but the younger cat was still staring out into the greyish, sleety well of the garden, beyond which you could just make out -- as a swelling line of shadow with low clouds racing over it -- the edge of the moor. Pam kept asking the cat what it could see. 'Nothing but old crimes out there,' she told it. 'Children buried all over the moor.'

People, too, come to life:

'As children none of the women in that family would ever go to sleep,' he had once written to me.

'You see them in photographs at three years old, almost blind with tiredness, puffy-eyed, heavy-lidded as vamps from a silent film, white, thin, with expressions as old and vulnerable as baby mice. They won’t let go. They won’t give in. In later life, rather than sleep, they smoke another cigarette, make another cup of instant coffee, read another page of LOST HORIZON.'

---

'The first time I had a fit,' she said, 'I kept it from my mother because I saw a vision with it. I was only a child, really. The vision was very clear: a seashore, steep and with no sand, and men and women lying on some rocks in the sunshine like lizards, staring quite blankly at the spray as it exploded up in front of them; huge waves that might have been on a cinema screen for all the notice they took of them.'

She narrowed her eyes, puzzled.

'You wondered why they had so little common sense.'

She tried to push the cat off her bed, but it only bent its body in a rubbery way and avoided her hand. She yawned suddenly.

'At the same time,' she went on, after a pause, 'I could see that some spiders had made their webs between the rocks, just a foot or two above the tideline.' Though they trembled and were sometimes filled with spray like dewdrops so that they glittered in the sun, the webs remained unbroken. She couldn't describe, she said, the sense of frailty and anxiety with which this filled her. 'So close to all that violence. You wondered why they had so little common sense,' she repeated. 'The last thing I heard was someone warning me, "On your own you really can hear voices in the tide --"'

---

"As the train crawled the last mile into London, I had seen three sheets of newspaper fluttering round the upper floors of an office block like butterflies courting a flower. The Pleroma demands of us a passion for the world which, however distortedly, reflects it. I still remember the intelligent eagerness of the negro's smile -- how he always had to talk about the world -- the way his sharp-edged elegant cheekbones seemed, like tribal scars or a silk suit, to be more designed than organic."

This Pleroma, the spiritual realm described by the Gnostics, becomes the fascination of three Cambridge students who are led by an unreliable occultist, Yaxley, into a dangerous ritual:

'Nobody tricked them, or tried to pretend it would be easy. If you get anything out of an experiment like that, it's by keeping your head and taking your chance. If you try to move cautiously, you may never be allowed to move at all.'

He looked thoughtful.

'I've seen what happens to people who lose their nerve.'

'I'm sure,' I said.

'They were hardly recognisable, some of them.'

I put the teacup down.

'I don't want to know,' I said.

'I bet you don't.'

He smiled to himself.

'Oh, they were still alive,' he said softly, 'if that's what you're worried about.'

This occult experiment took place twenty years before the book begins. The rest of the novel shows the ripples and echoes of that impact, the distortions and revelations that it leaves behind.

'You're all right,' I told Pam, who was staring, puzzled, into the gathering dark, her head on one side and the tea towel held up to her mouth as if she thought she was going to be sick.

'It knows who we are,' she whispered. 'Despite the precautions, it always remembers us.'

Haunted and wounded by their experience, the characters do their best to lead normal human lives, but wherever they go, whatever they do, the Pleroma follows. Yet this haunting is not merely a series of threats and intrusions; it also provides revelations and everyday insights.

'Look, Lucas: the world's ours. We make it, minute to minute. Pam would never admit that. It frightened her to have responsibility for her own needs. She wanted the universe personalised. A father who would look out for her. Happy accidents. Gifts. Things that came demonstrably from outside, so she felt special. That's the biggest lie of all.'

As the characters age, the novel shows how they cope and adapt to their new circumstances, how they deal with outbursts of nightmare and equally shocking moments of beauty.

Harrison wrote THE COURSE OF THE HEART during what was, for him, a period of skepticism about genre limitations, and a search for methods of writing that would allow him to apply his own experience and sensibility to fiction. He was also concerned with the longing for transcendence, even if only through imagination and fantasy. The result is a book unafraid to confront the real world, unafraid to show, with candour and compassion, the frailty and endurance of everyday lives within a context of impossible events.

I find THE COURSE OF THE HEART excellent both as fantasy and as a novel: emotionally compelling, aesthetically thrilling, honest, and in the end, moving.

No comments: